MLCad vs Stud.io: Which LEGO CAD Is Right for You?Choosing a LEGO CAD (computer-aided design) tool means balancing workflow, part libraries, rendering, community support, and personal goals. Two popular options are MLCad — a long-standing classic in the LEGO digital building community — and Stud.io — a modern, user-friendly platform with integrated rendering and marketplace features. Below is an in-depth comparison to help you decide which is right for your needs.
Quick summary
- MLCad: Best if you want a lightweight, fast program focused on classic LDraw-based building with precise control and scripting-friendly integration.
- Stud.io: Best if you want an all-in-one modern experience with easy part selection, built-in rendering, inventory/BOM features, and tight integration with BrickLink.
Origins and ecosystem
MLCad
- MLCad (Mike’s LEGO CAD) was developed in the early 2000s as a Windows desktop application built on the LDraw parts library. It’s mature and familiar to long-time LDraw community members.
- Relies on the LDraw parts library for parts; benefits from years of community-created parts and compatibility with other LDraw tools.
Stud.io
- Stud.io is an up-to-date CAD developed by BrickLink (now owned by the LEGO Group) with a modern UI and features aimed at hobbyists and designers who want an integrated workflow from design to parts purchase.
- Uses BrickLink’s own catalog and synchronizes with BrickLink inventory, pricing, and marketplace.
User interface & learning curve
MLCad
- Interface is utilitarian and minimalist; geared toward experienced users who prefer keyboard shortcuts and precise numeric input.
- Steeper initial learning curve for beginners unfamiliar with LDraw conventions and less guided help inside the app.
- Excellent for quick placement and tight control over part orientation and connection.
Stud.io
- Modern, polished interface with drag-and-drop, thumbnails, and visual part browsing that’s friendly for beginners.
- Built-in tutorials, context menus, and immediate visual feedback reduce friction for new users.
- Easier to sketch ideas quickly without memorizing commands.
Parts library and compatibility
MLCad
- Uses LDraw parts — extensive, community-maintained, and compatible across many LDraw tools (LDView, LPub3D, LeoCAD, etc.).
- If a part isn’t in LDraw, users can add or import custom parts, but this can require additional tools and file-format familiarity.
Stud.io
- Deep integration with BrickLink’s catalog and a large, actively updated set of parts, including more recent LEGO releases.
- Easier to add custom parts via .ldr/.dat support and built-in import tools; many users find the process more straightforward.
Building precision and control
MLCad
- High precision with numeric input for coordinates and rotations; ideal for advanced connection work, nonstandard techniques, and LDraw-accurate models.
- Works well with external LDraw utilities and script workflows for automation or batch tasks.
Stud.io
- Strong snapping and connection system for standard builds; also offers ‘advanced connect’ tools for micro-adjustments.
- Some purists argue it abstracts away low-level LDraw details, which can be both a benefit (simplicity) and a limitation (less raw control).
Rendering, presentation & documentation
MLCad
- Primarily a design tool; rendering requires external viewers (e.g., LDView, POV-Ray with exported scene files) and additional setup for photorealistic results.
- LPub3D or other tools are often used for building step-by-step instructions and parts lists.
Stud.io
- Built-in rendering (powered by a renderer like Cycles or equivalent) with lighting presets, camera controls, and high-quality output inside the app.
- Generates step instructions, BOM (bill of materials), and parts lists with pricing; direct export to BrickLink for buying parts.
Parts lists, pricing, and integration with marketplaces
MLCad
- Can export parts lists (through LPub3D or custom scripts), but market-price lookup and purchase workflows are not native.
- Better for users who want raw files for interoperability and separate procurement steps.
Stud.io
- Tight BrickLink integration: live part pricing, inventory sync, and an easy route to buy parts and list your MOC on BrickLink.
- BOM and pack/kit creation are built into the workflow, which is a huge convenience when moving from digital model to real build.
Community, support & file formats
MLCad
- Strong presence in the LDraw community and legacy forums; abundant legacy documentation and third-party tools exist.
- Uses LDraw (.ldr/.dat) file formats that are widely supported across numerous LEGO CAD tools.
Stud.io
- Active user base on BrickLink and the BrickLink Studio community; official support and frequent updates from BrickLink.
- Uses its own project files but supports import/export with LDraw formats and common image/render outputs.
Performance & platform support
MLCad
- Lightweight and fast on older hardware; Windows-focused (runs best on Windows; may require Wine on macOS/Linux).
- Low system requirements compared to modern rendering-heavy apps.
Stud.io
- Cross-platform installers available for Windows and macOS; may be heavier due to rendering features.
- Requires more modern hardware for comfortable rendering and large models.
Best-for scenarios (short guidance)
- If you want lightweight, precise LDraw-native modeling, or you’re deeply embedded in the LDraw toolchain: choose MLCad.
- If you want an easy-to-learn interface, built-in rendering and step-generation, plus direct BrickLink integration for buying parts: choose Stud.io.
- If you value both precision and modern conveniences, consider using both: design or refine complex connections in MLCad, then import into Stud.io for rendering and BOM/marketplace workflows.
Pros & cons comparison
| Feature | MLCad | Stud.io |
|---|---|---|
| Ease of learning | Good for experienced users; steeper for newbies | Beginner-friendly; modern UI |
| Parts library | LDraw (extensive, community) | BrickLink catalog (up-to-date) |
| Precision control | Excellent (numeric control) | Very good (user-friendly tools) |
| Rendering | External tools required | Built-in high-quality rendering |
| BOM & marketplace | Manual/export workflows | Integrated BrickLink pricing & buying |
| Platform support | Windows (lightweight) | Windows/macOS (heavier) |
| Community & updates | Mature LDraw community | Active BrickLink/Studio community |
Recommendations and workflow examples
- Quick MOC with purchase: Start in Stud.io for fast part selection, render, and buy parts through BrickLink.
- Highly technical connection or LDraw-only project: Model in MLCad for fine control; export .ldr and use LDView/LPub3D for instructions and POV-Ray for advanced renders.
- Hybrid workflow: Use MLCad for tricky subassemblies, export and import into Stud.io for final layout, rendering, and BOM.
Final verdict
- Choose MLCad if you prioritize LDraw compatibility, low resource usage, and fine-grained control for advanced techniques.
- Choose Stud.io if you want a modern, integrated toolkit with easier learning curve, built-in rendering, and direct BrickLink marketplace features.
Both are capable tools; the right one depends on whether you value classic precision and LDraw interoperability (MLCad) or convenience, visuals, and marketplace integration (Stud.io).
Leave a Reply